search
Sections List
American Journal News

The GOP's jobs plan is 92% smaller than Biden's

It doesn’t even come close to covering the ground the American Jobs Plan does.

By Josh Israel - April 27, 2021
Share
President Joe Biden

Senate Republicans countered President Joe Biden’s $2.25 trillion jobs package last week with what they called a $568 billion plan focused on traditional infrastructure. But a new analysis reveals that the GOP alternative really would only provide about $189 billion more than the status quo.

Biden’s American Jobs Plan would provide billions in new investments in roads, bridges, water systems, broadband, transit, child care, caregiving, and clean energy.

Though polling shows more than two-thirds of Americans back Biden’s proposals and strongly support all of its major provisions, Congressional Republicans have attacked this plan as “socialism” and complained that the climate and human infrastructure provisions in the bill do not match up with their definition of the word “infrastructure.”

After promising a counter-proposal focused narrowly on more traditional infrastructure, with a budget targeted in the “sweet spot” of between $600 billion to $800 billion, Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV) unveiled her party’s plan on Thursday. She proposed spending just $568 billion for transportation, water systems, and broadband, and nothing for green energy, combating climate change, housing, child care, or caregiving. She said the plan — also backed by GOP Sens. John Barrasso (WY), Mike Crapo (ID), Pat Toomey (PA), and Roger Wicker (MS) — was a “robust package” and a “good starting point” for negotiations with Biden.

At face value, that plan appeared to be about 25% of Biden’s proposal. Capito told Fox News on Friday that if you ignore all of the omitted priorities, it was not all that different from the American Jobs Plan.

“I think if you took the president’s plan — his $2.2 trillion plan — and you really pulled out those areas of physical core infrastructure that we think is critically important, and you matched it, apples to apples, we’re not nearly as far apart as it might seem,” she claimed. “I mean, we are far apart, but not nearly to a trillion, trillions of dollars.” The two bills cover a different number of years, making an exact comparison difficult.

But a Washington Post analysis on Monday revealed that Capito’s bill isn’t even close on the common priorities. The Post noted that while Biden’s plan calls for additional spending, Capito’s numbers include $379 billion in baseline spending that would happen already, adjusted for inflation. Instead of spending $360 billion on traditional surface transportation, as would likely happen with no bill, the GOP plan would spend $393 billion — an increase of just $33 billion.

“In all, it looks like the GOP plan would add $189 billion to the baseline of current spending,” the Post concluded, “compared to Biden’s $785 billion for the same line items.”

A separate opinion piece published by the Post on Monday noted that this $189 billion increase represents only about 24% of what Biden proposes for those areas the GOP calls “core” infrastructure. It also makes up just 8% of what Biden is proposing in overall new spending — a rather large gap.

A Capito spokesperson did not immediately respond to an inquiry for this story.

But Kevin DeGood, director of infrastructure policy at the Center for American Progress, said in an email that the GOP plan offers little to no new spending beyond the status quo, except for on aviation and broadband. “Calling Senator Capito’s plan an alternative is a farce,” he observed.

With narrow majorities in the House and Senate, if Democrats stay united they could pass Biden’s plan without a single GOP vote.

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
How many will lose health insurance under the Republican bill? The CBO says 13.7 million.

How many will lose health insurance under the Republican bill? The CBO says 13.7 million.

By Jesse Valentine - May 23, 2025
Rep. Bresnahan sold shares in PA companies ahead of market drop

Rep. Bresnahan sold shares in PA companies ahead of market drop

By Jesse Valentine - May 21, 2025
Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

By Jesse Valentine - May 20, 2025
Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

By Bonnie Fuller - May 16, 2025
It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

By Jesse Valentine - May 15, 2025
Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

By Jesse Valentine - May 14, 2025
Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

By Jesse Valentine - May 12, 2025
Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

By Jesse Valentine - May 09, 2025
Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

By Jesse Valentine - May 06, 2025
Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

By Jesse Valentine - May 05, 2025
Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - April 24, 2025
Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

By Jesse Valentine - April 22, 2025
Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

By Jesse Valentine - April 21, 2025
“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

By Bonnie Fuller - April 21, 2025
Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

By Jesse Valentine - April 17, 2025
Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

By Jesse Valentine - April 16, 2025
North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

By Jesse Valentine - April 11, 2025
Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

By Jesse Valentine - April 09, 2025
Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

By Jesse Valentine - April 08, 2025
Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025