search
Sections List
American Journal News

Third embarrassingly unqualified Trump judicial nominee drops out in shame

Considering Donald Trump is the least qualified person to ever attain the presidency of the United States, perhaps it makes sense that he keeps nominating people for the courts who are equally ill-equipped for the job. But that doesn’t make it any less embarrassing that a third nominee has now dropped out of the running […]

By Alison R. Parker - December 18, 2017
Share
Matthew Petersen
"I know nothing."

But that doesn’t make it any less embarrassing that a third nominee has now dropped out of the running in shame.

Matthew Petersen, Trump’s pick for a lifetime seat on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, withdrew his name from consideration Monday in the wake of a viral video showing just how little experience or knowledge he would bring to the bench.

Petersen currently serves on the Federal Election Commission and has never tried a case nor even argued a motion in court. And under questioning from senators during his nomination hearing last Wednesday, he fumbled and flailed his way from start to finish.

After confirming that he had vanishingly little experience anywhere near an actual courtroom, Petersen also acknowledged that he had not read the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure — the standards that govern cases in the court to which he was nominated — since law school, and could not offer any substantive answer when asked about various elements of the law.

Aderson Francois, a professor at Georgetown Law, noted that “a second year law student” could have answered the questions better than Petersen.

And when Rhode Island Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, who sits on the Judiciary Committee, tweeted a video of the painful exchanges, his commentary said it all.

Petersen was asked “basic questions of law & he can’t answer a single one. Hoo-boy,” Whitehouse wrote.

In his resignation letter to Trump, Petersen plaintively lamented that his void of knowledge and experience ended up being an issue.

“I had hoped that my nearly two decades of public service might carry more weight than my two worst minutes on television,” he wrote.

Petersen joins two other absurdly unqualified Trump nominees who have dropped out of consideration.

Brett Talley, whom Trump picked for the U.S. District Court in Alabama, withdrew his name after a host of controversial issues arose in the wake of his nomination. He failed to disclose that his wife is chief of staff to White House counsel Don McGahn, and his response to the Sandy Hook massacre was to bemoan America as a “society of pansies.”

Further, Talley has been unanimously declared “not qualified” by the American Bar Association, which ought to have tipped Trump off.

And Jeff Mateer, whom Trump had chosen for a district court post in Texas, is also no longer in the running after hateful comments he made about LGBTQ people emerged. Mateer referred to transgender children as “Satan’s plan,” and called same-sex marriage “disgusting” and potentially leading to bestiality or polygamy.

Even Iowa Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley thought Mateer and Talley were too unqualified and extreme to move forward.

Petersen is the third strike for Trump when it comes to choosing people for the bench who actually belong there. Unlike his own experience, perhaps Trump will learn that being manifestly unqualified for a job is not actually an asset.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

By Bonnie Fuller - May 16, 2025
It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

By Jesse Valentine - May 15, 2025
Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

By Jesse Valentine - May 14, 2025
Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

By Jesse Valentine - May 12, 2025
Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

By Jesse Valentine - May 09, 2025
Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

By Jesse Valentine - May 06, 2025
Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

By Jesse Valentine - May 05, 2025
Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - April 24, 2025
Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

By Jesse Valentine - April 22, 2025
Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

By Jesse Valentine - April 21, 2025
“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

By Bonnie Fuller - April 21, 2025
Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

By Jesse Valentine - April 17, 2025
Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

By Jesse Valentine - April 16, 2025
North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

By Jesse Valentine - April 11, 2025
Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

By Jesse Valentine - April 09, 2025
Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

By Jesse Valentine - April 08, 2025
Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Trump’s antiwar claims don’t hold up in leaked group chat

Trump’s antiwar claims don’t hold up in leaked group chat

By Jesse Valentine - March 28, 2025
Frontline Republican governors cheer on Department of Ed closure

Frontline Republican governors cheer on Department of Ed closure

By Jesse Valentine - March 26, 2025