search
Sections List
American Journal News

Democratic judge says abortion is defining issue in Pennsylvania Supreme Court race

‘In Pennsylvania, we elect judges, and people have a right to know where you stand on those issues,’ Daniel McCaffery said.

By Rebekah Sager - October 17, 2023
Share
Candidate for Pennsylvania Supreme Court Judge Daniel McCaffery speaks at a women's organizing event and canvass launch in Norristown, PA Saturday, Sept. 30, 2023. (AP Photo/Ryan Collerd)
Candidate for Pennsylvania Supreme Court Judge Daniel McCaffery speaks at a women's organizing event and canvass launch in Norristown, PA Saturday, Sept. 30, 2023. (AP Photo/Ryan Collerd)

One of the most-watched races in Pennsylvania is the battle between Democratic Judge Daniel McCaffery and his Republican opponent, Judge Carolyn Carluccio.

McCaffery told the American Independent Foundation that the U.S. Supreme Court ruling on Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization that overturned Roe v. Wade will be the defining issue in the race, adding that there are parallels between Carluccio and former President Donald Trump’s U.S. Supreme Court nominees.

“I mean, you had three individuals appointed by former President Trump that stood in front of the American public, each one of them answered questions the way that you would expect them regarding precedent, regarding stare decisis (Latin for “things decided”). And each one of them promised to follow the law,” McCaffery said. “And then each one of them basically overturned the law or changed the law and changed precedent, and disregarded what they said to the American public.”

Five of the seven justices on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court are Democrats. Although the open seat that McCaffery and Carluccio are running for will not upset the balance of power, three seats will be on the ballot in 2025.

Carluccio, a judge on the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas, removed anti-abortion language from her campaign’s website after she won the Republican primary. She has been endorsed by two anti-abortion groups, the Pennsylvania Pro-Life Federation and the Pro-Life Coalition of Pennsylvania.

McCaffery noted that the issue of abortion care didn’t even come up until after the state primaries.

It wasn’t until the Republicans basically started running as pro-life champions; fetuses have First Amendment rights, Second Amendment rights, and then immediately post-primary completely changed or scrubbed their website of any reference to pro-life, and completely changed their position,” McCaffery said.

McCaffery explained that when it comes to what the nation is seeing in politically divided and partisan courts dates back to what he calls a 30- or 40-year effort by the Federalist Society to pack the courts with conservative judges.

Founded in 1982, the Federalist Society is a conservative legal organization with about 60,000 members.

During his term, Trump nominated 234 federal judges as well as Justices Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett, most of whom have ties to or are members of the Federalist Society.

“When you have somebody who runs as a pro-life candidate who basically tells people I’m an originalist. That’s kind of a code word for… I mean, who else described themselves as an originalist? Amy Coney Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh to Neil Gorsuch. They’re telling you how they’re going to rule on these particular cases.” McCaffery said.

Carluccio has refused to offer her opinions on the Dobbs decision or her thoughts on what would happen if the state’s Abortion Control Act were to be repealed. Following the Dobbs decision, Pennsylvania’s Republican-controlled House of Representatives tried to put a constitutional amendment before voters to say that abortion care was not protected in the Pennsylvania Constitution. In February, after three special elections, Democrats won the majority in the state House, gaining the power to block Republicans on abortion bans — including a constitutional amendment.

“In Pennsylvania, we elect judges, and people have a right to know where you stand on those issues. Because, and I mean this, I would much rather lose an election on the merits than win an election by being deceitful,” McCaffery said.

I think that Dobbs was wrongly decided. I think that abortion is literally covered under the privacy rights of our Constitution. I think Roe v. Wade was, in fact, good law. I think it was settled principle, settled precedent. And I can’t think of anything more private when you talk about privacy rights than that decision, which should be left between a woman, her doctor, and her conscience. Period. Full stop.

McCaffery said he sees a lot of similarities between what’s happening in the attacks against him and Republican attempts to impeach the newly seated liberal Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Janet Protasiewicz.

Wisconsin Assembly Speaker Robin Vos has threatened to impeach Protasiewicz unless she refuses to recuse herself from redistricting and abortion rights cases.

McCaffery said if these kinds of political moves continue to happen, it will impact democracy itself.

“We’re looking at the end of liberal democracy if people continue to politicize the courts and people lose faith in the rule of law, because that’s the only thing that stands between us and anarchy,” he said.

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

By Bonnie Fuller - May 16, 2025
Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Maine gun safety advocates launch citizen initiative to pass ‘red flag’ law

Maine gun safety advocates launch citizen initiative to pass ‘red flag’ law

By Emma Davis, Maine Morning Star - September 19, 2024
GOP Senate candidate received a tax break for a townhouse she doesn’t live in

GOP Senate candidate received a tax break for a townhouse she doesn’t live in

By Michelle Griffith, Minnesota Reformer - September 10, 2024
New NC GOP chair flirts with bogus stolen election conspiracies

New NC GOP chair flirts with bogus stolen election conspiracies

By Jesse Valentine - April 19, 2024
AJ News
Latest
Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

By Jesse Valentine - May 20, 2025
Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

By Bonnie Fuller - May 16, 2025
It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

By Jesse Valentine - May 15, 2025
Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

By Jesse Valentine - May 14, 2025
Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

By Jesse Valentine - May 12, 2025
Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

By Jesse Valentine - May 09, 2025
Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

By Jesse Valentine - May 06, 2025
Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

By Jesse Valentine - May 05, 2025
Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - April 24, 2025
Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

By Jesse Valentine - April 22, 2025
Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

By Jesse Valentine - April 21, 2025
“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

By Bonnie Fuller - April 21, 2025
Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

By Jesse Valentine - April 17, 2025
Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

By Jesse Valentine - April 16, 2025
North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

By Jesse Valentine - April 11, 2025
Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

By Jesse Valentine - April 09, 2025
Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

By Jesse Valentine - April 08, 2025
Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Trump’s antiwar claims don’t hold up in leaked group chat

Trump’s antiwar claims don’t hold up in leaked group chat

By Jesse Valentine - March 28, 2025