search
Sections List
American Journal News

GOP lawmaker: Trying to fix climate crisis is 'tantamount to genocide'

Rep. Rob Bishop also implied that death would be preferable to seeing the Green New Deal become law.

By Dan Desai Martin - March 14, 2019
Share
Rep. Rob Bishop

Outlandish Republican claims about the Green New Deal, the progressive plan to ensure future generations have clean air and clean water, took a decidedly dark turn Thursday morning when Rep. Rob Bishop (R-UT) claimed the ideas found in the Green New Deal are “tantamount to genocide.”

The remarks came at a Republican press conference demanding Democrats hold congressional hearings on the landmark climate legislation. Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy,  and, Bishop, the top Republican on the Natural Resources Committee, along with several other members, allege the Green New Deal goes too far. But none of the comments were as startling as Bishop’s.

Following the press conference, Axios reminded him that genocide means killing a group of people based on their ethnicity or belonging to a certain group. Rather than rephrase, Bishop stood by his remarks, saying, “I’m an ethnic. I’m a westerner.”

Pushed further and asked if he thought implementing the Green New Deal would literally kill him, Bishop not only said yes, he said that death would be preferable.

“Killing would be positive if you implement everything the Green New Deal actually wants to,” Bishop said. “That’s why the the Green New Deal is not ready for prime time.”

But the Green New Deal does not call for the large-scale massacre of any group of people. It doesn’t call for killing anyone at all. It simply acknowledges that climate change is real and offers a series of policy prescriptions to address and mitigate the man-made causes of climate change.

The bill, championed by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-OR), hopes to address climate-change crisis.

A recent report from top scientists says that countries only have about 12 years left to address climate change before devastating outcomes become inevitable. The report warns of famine, refugee crises, sea level rises, increasingly powerful storms, and massive droughts if Republicans have their way and significant changes do not take place.

But when lawmakers step forward to address the crisis, Republicans mock the efforts and lie about what the impact will be. Trump lied about the plan, saying it would eliminate air travel. Rep. Liz Cheney (R-WY), a member of the House Republican leadership team, lied and said the plan would outlaw cars. Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY), chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee, went so far as to say the bill would ban ice cream (spoiler: it won’t).

But those lies pale in comparison to Bishop, who blithely likened the bill’s passage to atrocities committed by Hitler and other of history’s worst murderers.

Republican hyperbole is nothing new. Republicans have called Social Security a “folly,” warned that Medicare and Medicaid would usher in socialism, and predicted “death panels” if the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, became law.

Bishop’s new accusations that liken the Green New Deal to genocide are as wrong as they are appalling.

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
Earle-Sears backed offshore drilling plan that risked 46,000 Virginia jobs

Earle-Sears backed offshore drilling plan that risked 46,000 Virginia jobs

By Jesse Valentine - July 23, 2025
Whitehouse urges his colleagues to get serious about climate change for the 300th time

Whitehouse urges his colleagues to get serious about climate change for the 300th time

By Jesse Valentine - July 17, 2025
Republicans spread misinformation and lies as California burns

Republicans spread misinformation and lies as California burns

By Jesse Valentine - January 09, 2025
Feds to issue grants to support NC residents experiencing homelessness due to Hurricane Helene

Feds to issue grants to support NC residents experiencing homelessness due to Hurricane Helene

By Greg Childress, NC Newsline - October 11, 2024
Biden pledges federal help for states in the Southeast stricken by catastrophic storm

Biden pledges federal help for states in the Southeast stricken by catastrophic storm

By Jennifer Shutt, States Newsroom - September 30, 2024
Ohio GOP Senate candidate Bernie Moreno takes anti-immigrant, pro-fossil fuel message on tour

Ohio GOP Senate candidate Bernie Moreno takes anti-immigrant, pro-fossil fuel message on tour

By Nick Evans, Ohio Capital Journal - August 08, 2024
AJ News
Latest
Whatley campaign tied to company accused of preying on veterans

Whatley campaign tied to company accused of preying on veterans

By Jesse Valentine - November 06, 2025
‘Ticket to Ride’ and pickle sandwiches: The family life behind Abigail Spanberger’s campaign

‘Ticket to Ride’ and pickle sandwiches: The family life behind Abigail Spanberger’s campaign

By Bonnie Fuller - November 03, 2025
Republican John Reid says Confederate generals were “remarkable people”

Republican John Reid says Confederate generals were “remarkable people”

By Jesse Valentine - October 31, 2025
RFK Jr. is going to war against abortion pills

RFK Jr. is going to war against abortion pills

By Bonnie Fuller - October 31, 2025
Ciattarelli wants to end the immigration policy that made his family American

Ciattarelli wants to end the immigration policy that made his family American

By Jesse Valentine - October 31, 2025
Collins says she opposed GOP bill—then brags about writing it

Collins says she opposed GOP bill—then brags about writing it

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2025
Some of Jack Ciattarelli’s biggest donors have criminal records

Some of Jack Ciattarelli’s biggest donors have criminal records

By Jesse Valentine - October 27, 2025
GOP Rep. Mike Lawler raises money for radical anti-abortion group

GOP Rep. Mike Lawler raises money for radical anti-abortion group

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2025
Lavish White House spending persists as federal workers go unpaid

Lavish White House spending persists as federal workers go unpaid

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2025
Miyares’ record shows a long history of siding with landlords over renters

Miyares’ record shows a long history of siding with landlords over renters

By Jesse Valentine - October 16, 2025
Lombardo voted by mail. Now, he wants to restrict it.

Lombardo voted by mail. Now, he wants to restrict it.

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2025
Miller-Meeks digs in, says no to health care savings for Iowans

Miller-Meeks digs in, says no to health care savings for Iowans

By Jesse Valentine - October 14, 2025
Tom Barrett promoted GOP budget by passing off a political insider as a small business owner

Tom Barrett promoted GOP budget by passing off a political insider as a small business owner

By Jesse Valentine - October 10, 2025
Republican Rep. Rob Wittman under fire for fundraising during shutdown

Republican Rep. Rob Wittman under fire for fundraising during shutdown

By Jesse Valentine - October 08, 2025
Jason Miyares advanced an extreme anti-abortion agenda as Virginia attorney general

Jason Miyares advanced an extreme anti-abortion agenda as Virginia attorney general

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2025
NEWSLETTER: A new generation of Trump grifters

NEWSLETTER: A new generation of Trump grifters

By Jesse Valentine - October 06, 2025
Texas wanted to force her US Marine vet husband to watch their baby die—it would have been worse than war

Texas wanted to force her US Marine vet husband to watch their baby die—it would have been worse than war

By Bonnie Fuller - October 02, 2025
Tumblr linked to Republican John Reid engaged with Nazi porn accounts

Tumblr linked to Republican John Reid engaged with Nazi porn accounts

By Jesse Valentine - October 01, 2025
Spanberger speaks: How she’ll fight Medicaid cuts, create more affordable housing, and protect public schools

Spanberger speaks: How she’ll fight Medicaid cuts, create more affordable housing, and protect public schools

By Bonnie Fuller - September 25, 2025
Republican Josh Williams: I support tax breaks for the rich

Republican Josh Williams: I support tax breaks for the rich

By Jesse Valentine - September 25, 2025
Whatley leans on election deniers, alleged abusers to fund North Carolina Senate run

Whatley leans on election deniers, alleged abusers to fund North Carolina Senate run

By Jesse Valentine - September 24, 2025
NEWSLETTER: wake up

NEWSLETTER: wake up

By Jesse Valentine - September 19, 2025
House Democrats demand answers on Jimmy Kimmel firing

House Democrats demand answers on Jimmy Kimmel firing

By Jesse Valentine - September 18, 2025
Can Democrats defeat Andy Ogles?

Can Democrats defeat Andy Ogles?

By Jesse Valentine - September 18, 2025
J.D. Vance jokes about White House committing war crimes

J.D. Vance jokes about White House committing war crimes

By Jesse Valentine - September 18, 2025
NRSC uses edited clip to falsely tie Cooper to Charlotte stabbing

NRSC uses edited clip to falsely tie Cooper to Charlotte stabbing

By Jesse Valentine - September 12, 2025
Public school defender Ghazala Hashmi takes on right-wing radio’s Reid for lieutenant governor

Public school defender Ghazala Hashmi takes on right-wing radio’s Reid for lieutenant governor

By Bonnie Fuller - September 12, 2025
Texas’ newest abortion law allows $100,000 rewards for snitching on pregnant women

Texas’ newest abortion law allows $100,000 rewards for snitching on pregnant women

By Bonnie Fuller - September 10, 2025
Collins slams ‘outside money’ before heading to Hollywood for fundraiser

Collins slams ‘outside money’ before heading to Hollywood for fundraiser

By Jesse Valentine - September 10, 2025
Iowa Rep. Miller-Meeks balks at concerns of mobile home residents

Iowa Rep. Miller-Meeks balks at concerns of mobile home residents

By Jesse Valentine - September 09, 2025
NEWSLETTER: Trump blew up a boat

NEWSLETTER: Trump blew up a boat

By Jesse Valentine - September 06, 2025
FACT CHECK: Yes, Wes Moore did receive a Bronze Star for heroism

FACT CHECK: Yes, Wes Moore did receive a Bronze Star for heroism

By Jesse Valentine - September 02, 2025
In her own words: Why this Texas physician now helps women in Virginia

In her own words: Why this Texas physician now helps women in Virginia

By Bonnie Fuller - September 02, 2025
NEWSLETTER: Gavin Newsom’s noncompliance

NEWSLETTER: Gavin Newsom’s noncompliance

By Jesse Valentine - August 22, 2025

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License .