search
Sections List
American Journal News

These cities keep trying to ban abortion even though the Constitution says they can't

The ACLU says it will not back down from fighting back against the unlawful bans.

By Lisa Needham - September 18, 2020
Share
Abortion rights demonstration in Texas.

Lubbock is the latest city in Texas to try to declare itself a “sanctuary city for the unborn.” It’s one of several municipalities that are openly defying the Constitution by functionally enacting a complete abortion ban within their borders.

Since mid-2019, at least 13 cities in Texas have considered such ordinances, and 11 cities in East Texas passed an anti-abortion sanctuary city law. None of those cities had an abortion clinic.

Almost immediately, seven of those East Texas cities were sued by the American Civil Liberties Union Each city’s ordinance declared abortion providers “criminal entities,” attempting to criminalize a constitutional right. The ACLU dropped the lawsuit after all the municipalities removed the criminal entity language. 

The East Texas Right to Life association, which is behind the sanctuary city movement, spun the language change as a victory that would “further ensure that the abortion industry had no chance of convincing a judge to entertain their weak accusations” and said that labeling abortion providers “criminal organizations” was still accurate. The ACLU indicated the language change was “far from perfect,” and they would keep monitoring the language in the ordinances. 

Another lawsuit is still in the works, however. Three organizations that support abortion rights — the Afiya Center, the Lilith Fund, and the Texas Equal Access Fund — sued both East Texas Right to Life and its leader, Mark Dickson. The organizations allege Dickson and East Texas Right to Life defamed their organizations by calling them criminals when they know that is not the case. 

Dickson bragged that getting sued was a victory. He said that defaming the organizations by calling them “criminals” is a statement “rooted not in my own imagination, but in the law written on all of our hearts, in the Constitution of the United States of America, in the Texas Constitution, and in the laws of the great State of Texas.”

Of course, abortion has been enshrined as a constitutional right for nearly 50 years, regardless of what Dickson believes. Dickson is not the only person pursuing this quixotic line of reasoning, though. Twelve Texas residents have sued the three women’s health organizations, saying that the defamation lawsuit is a “deliberate campaign to muzzle the voices of those who support life.” Their logic? Since Texas didn’t repeat its pre-Roe v. Wade statutes criminalizing abortion, it’s still a crime in Texas. That ignores the fact that the Constitution trumps any state law Texas might want to claim is still in effect. 

Meanwhile, Lubbock is soldiering onward with an equally misguided attempt, led once again by Dickson, to ban abortion there. The proposed ordinance would make it unlawful to “procure or perform” an abortion in Lubbock. It would also make it illegal for someone to drive someone to an abortion, give someone money to use for an abortion, or give instructions about self-administered abortions. Further, it would provide members of the fetus’s family the right to sue the provider for emotional distress. 

Lubbock is the epicenter of the latest fight because, unlike the small East Texas cities already sued by the ACLU, a health center that offers abortion will be coming to Lubbock. Planned Parenthood has said it is hiring for a new facility in Lubbock, though an opening date is not yet set. 

Many elected officials in Lubbock are not excited about the idea of the ban ordinance. The city’s “unequivocally pro-life” mayor, Dan Pope, said that telling businesses, including Planned Parenthood, what they can do is “not the lane we need to be in. We need to do the things we were elected to do: provide police and fire services, make sure that our parks are maintained, make sure that we take care of our streets.”

Other officials are equally worried. Lubbock’s city manager said that he has “no ability to enforce an ordinance like this without exposing the city to significant legal and financial risk.”

This concern is warranted. A city in Tennessee, Mt. Juliet, just settled a case with an abortion clinic after that city approved a zoning scheme designed to prevent carafem, an abortion provider, from operating there. After the city passed the zoning laws, the ACLU sued on behalf of carafem. In May, a federal court issued a preliminary injunction blocking the ordinance, saying carafem was likely to prevail at trial.

With the settlement, Mt. Juliet has to allow carafem to perform abortions anywhere the city otherwise allows medical services. Moreover, the city had to agree to pay $225,000 in legal fees, which the city attorney referred to as “a bitter pill to swallow.”

The ACLU has stated it will not back down on these lawsuits. They’re monitoring the language in the Texas sanctuary city cases. And in Tennessee, Andrew Beck, of the ACLU Reproductive Freedom Project, warned lawmakers, saying, “if you attack your constituents’ constitutional right to abortion, we will see you in court. And we will win.”

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
Democrats sweep House and Senate in historic victory

Democrats sweep House and Senate in historic victory

By Jesse Valentine - November 05, 2026
Susan Collins’ reign ends

Susan Collins’ reign ends

By Jesse Valentine - November 05, 2026
Data center giants are funneling cash to Republican candidates

Data center giants are funneling cash to Republican candidates

By Jesse Valentine - November 02, 2026
State Senate candidate Trevor Jung: Republicans are too ‘lazy’ to help working families

State Senate candidate Trevor Jung: Republicans are too ‘lazy’ to help working families

By Bonnie Fuller - October 30, 2026
Roger Marshall took $38,500 from HSA industry

Roger Marshall took $38,500 from HSA industry

By Jesse Valentine - October 30, 2026
John James took $1.2 million from Epstein-linked donors

John James took $1.2 million from Epstein-linked donors

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2026
Did Brian Mast’s company get a farm credit for undeveloped land?

Did Brian Mast’s company get a farm credit for undeveloped land?

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2026
Roger Marshall’s Facebook posts don’t match his travel records

Roger Marshall’s Facebook posts don’t match his travel records

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2026
Jeanine Driscoll dismisses voters’ concerns about gas prices

Jeanine Driscoll dismisses voters’ concerns about gas prices

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2026
Army vet candidate Ben Brist in AD-61: Ban school vouchers, keep abortion legal

Army vet candidate Ben Brist in AD-61: Ban school vouchers, keep abortion legal

By Bonnie Fuller - October 27, 2026
School board attacks on Villegas proven to be misleading

School board attacks on Villegas proven to be misleading

By Jesse Valentine - October 23, 2026
Talarico vs. Paxton: What the Senate race means for women’s health and maternal mortality in Texas

Talarico vs. Paxton: What the Senate race means for women’s health and maternal mortality in Texas

By Bonnie Fuller - October 23, 2026
Lawsuit against Shannon Taylor comes from GOP-linked law firm

Lawsuit against Shannon Taylor comes from GOP-linked law firm

By Jesse Valentine - October 23, 2026
Jenny Costa Honeycutt opposed affordable housing, backed developers

Jenny Costa Honeycutt opposed affordable housing, backed developers

By Jesse Valentine - October 23, 2026
Data center donors pour millions into competitive U.S. Senate races

Data center donors pour millions into competitive U.S. Senate races

By Jesse Valentine - October 23, 2026
Ramaswamy has business ties to China’s Communist Party

Ramaswamy has business ties to China’s Communist Party

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2026
Graham took campaign cash from Epstein-linked billionaires

Graham took campaign cash from Epstein-linked billionaires

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2026
Tom Tiffany pledged to protect Social Security. His record tells another story.

Tom Tiffany pledged to protect Social Security. His record tells another story.

By Jesse Valentine - October 21, 2026
DiLorenzo has millions tied to offshore tax havens

DiLorenzo has millions tied to offshore tax havens

By Jesse Valentine - October 21, 2026
Sununu’s lobbying firm sought tariff relief for big corporations

Sununu’s lobbying firm sought tariff relief for big corporations

By Jesse Valentine - October 20, 2026
False attack ad says Benitez-Thompson backed early release for killers

False attack ad says Benitez-Thompson backed early release for killers

By Jesse Valentine - October 20, 2026
Drazan staffer had teaching license revoked for alleged sexual misconduct

Drazan staffer had teaching license revoked for alleged sexual misconduct

By Jesse Valentine - October 20, 2026
False ad distorts Amish Shah’s record on sex offenders

False ad distorts Amish Shah’s record on sex offenders

By Jesse Valentine - October 20, 2026
Wife of Lombardo campaign manager marched with Jan. 6 rioters

Wife of Lombardo campaign manager marched with Jan. 6 rioters

By Jesse Valentine - October 16, 2026
Examining Mike Turner’s pro-war record

Examining Mike Turner’s pro-war record

By Jesse Valentine - October 16, 2026
Collins backed DOJ officials who dismantled public corruption unit

Collins backed DOJ officials who dismantled public corruption unit

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2026
Mike Rounds’ private flights cost taxpayers millions

Mike Rounds’ private flights cost taxpayers millions

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2026
Sununu opposed crackdowns on corporate tax shelters

Sununu opposed crackdowns on corporate tax shelters

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2026
David Flippo’s campaign is backed by election deniers

David Flippo’s campaign is backed by election deniers

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2026
Misleading ads attack Democrats over ACA subsidies GOP let expire

Misleading ads attack Democrats over ACA subsidies GOP let expire

By Jesse Valentine - October 14, 2026
Tom Kean helped Big Pharma protect billions in cancer drug sales

Tom Kean helped Big Pharma protect billions in cancer drug sales

By Jesse Valentine - October 14, 2026
Biggs voted against barring sex offenders from security jobs

Biggs voted against barring sex offenders from security jobs

By Jesse Valentine - October 09, 2026
Greg Cunningham ad omits required military disclaimer

Greg Cunningham ad omits required military disclaimer

By Jesse Valentine - October 09, 2026
Paxton signals openness to Social Security cuts in leaked audio

Paxton signals openness to Social Security cuts in leaked audio

By Jesse Valentine - October 09, 2026
Science, healthcare, and the wealth gap: Why Stefany Shaheen is running for Congress

Science, healthcare, and the wealth gap: Why Stefany Shaheen is running for Congress

By Bonnie Fuller - October 09, 2026
Stelson campaign did not employ undocumented immigrant, despite WH claims

Stelson campaign did not employ undocumented immigrant, despite WH claims

By Jesse Valentine - October 08, 2026
Zach Lahn Wants to ban H-1B hiring after benefitting from it

Zach Lahn Wants to ban H-1B hiring after benefitting from it

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2026
Ryan Elijah says mother’s debilitating fall was “God opening a door”

Ryan Elijah says mother’s debilitating fall was “God opening a door”

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2026
Garrity slams executive order protecting abortion seekers

Garrity slams executive order protecting abortion seekers

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2026
Finstad voted against lower drug costs on first day in Congress

Finstad voted against lower drug costs on first day in Congress

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2026

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License .