search
Sections List
American Journal News

French fire chief slams Trump's 'utterly useless' advice on Notre Dame

‘Everything would have collapsed’ if French firefighters had followed Trump’s absurd suggestion of using water-bombing aircraft to fight the fire at Notre Dame.

By Oliver Willis - April 17, 2019
Share
Donald Trump

A leading French fire chief says that if first responders had followed Trump’s “risible” unsolicited advice on how to fight the fire at Notre Dame, it would have created a major disaster at the historic site.

“Everything would have collapsed,” Lieutenant-Colonel Michael Bernier explained to Agence-France Presse on Tuesday, if fire crews had used aerial water bombers on the cathedral as Trump suggested. “It was technically impossible, undoable and most of all would have been utterly useless,” Bernier added.

Bernier is a spokesman for Sécurité Civile, the French civil defense agency.

Sécurité Civile was forced to use its Twitter account to quickly shut down Trump’s suggestion after he made it. As Notre Dame was burning before the world’s horrified eyes on Monday, Trump tweeted: “Perhaps flying water tankers could be used to put it out. Must act quickly!”

“All means are being used, except for water-bombing aircrafts which, if used, could lead to the collapse of the entire structure of the cathedral,” the agency wrote in response.

Bernier elaborated on just how stupid Trump’s idea was, noting that dropping the amount of water typically used to fight forest fires from a Canadair water bomber would have been “the equivalent of dropping three tonnes of concrete at 250 kilometers per hour (155mph).”

“It would have been like bowling with the cathedral,” he added, and “the two towers might have fallen” as a result.

Trump’s suggested course of action would have also endangered other buildings in the neighborhood, Bernier said: “Neighboring buildings would have been hit by flying blocks of hot stone, and the whole area would have had to be evacuated.”

Bernier also pointed out that Trump’s uninformed recommendation would have endangered the lives of more than 500 firefighters who were on the scene doing real work while Trump was safely tweeting from the White House.

Trump’s harmful comments about Notre Dame on Monday didn’t stop with his ignorant tweet. He also made a bizarre comment about the fire that hinted at false conspiracy theories surrounding the event.

Authorities believe that the fire was an accident related to ongoing renovations at Notre Dame. Trump, however, decided to muse: “Renovation, you know, what’s that all about?”

Trump is of course an infamous conspiracy theorist who for years pushed the false, racist conspiracy theory that President Barack Obama was not born in the United States.

Perhaps aware that Trump had once again humiliated America by shooting off at the mouth, White House press secretary Sarah Sanders tried to clean up after him — the day after the fire — with a press release about Notre Dame that pretended Trump had never made his bizarre suggestion.

Trump is a ridiculous international figure. Americans know it. Citizens across the globe know it. And this week, firefighters in France were forced to call it out when they had much more important things to do.

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation. 


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
Dan Sullivan skipped half of fisheries hearings

Dan Sullivan skipped half of fisheries hearings

By - September 11, 2026
Rick Jackson’s lobbying record complicates outsider image

Rick Jackson’s lobbying record complicates outsider image

By Jesse Valentine - September 11, 2026
Republican ad distorts Mendoza’s tax comments

Republican ad distorts Mendoza’s tax comments

By Jesse Valentine - September 11, 2026
Ty Masterson ran a business that filed for bankruptcy

Ty Masterson ran a business that filed for bankruptcy

By Jesse Valentine - September 10, 2026
Drazan’s record favors Oregon landlords

Drazan’s record favors Oregon landlords

By Jesse Valentine - September 10, 2026
O’Donnell says storing nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain is a “complicated question”

O’Donnell says storing nuclear waste at Yucca Mountain is a “complicated question”

By Jesse Valentine - September 10, 2026
Sununu backed bills that added trillions to debt and deficit

Sununu backed bills that added trillions to debt and deficit

By Jesse Valentine - September 09, 2026
Susan Collins voted against pay equity, sick leave

Susan Collins voted against pay equity, sick leave

By Jesse Valentine - September 08, 2026
A Las Vegas woman’s abortion story—and why she’s voting yes on Question 6

A Las Vegas woman’s abortion story—and why she’s voting yes on Question 6

By Bonnie Fuller - September 04, 2026
Roger Marshall has an Epstein files problem

Roger Marshall has an Epstein files problem

By Jesse Valentine - September 04, 2026
Lahn’s running mate has deep ties to big ag

Lahn’s running mate has deep ties to big ag

By Jesse Valentine - September 03, 2026
Aaron Flint misleads voters about Montana’s congressional district

Aaron Flint misleads voters about Montana’s congressional district

By Jesse Valentine - September 03, 2026
Garrity helped lead super polluter that offshored jobs

Garrity helped lead super polluter that offshored jobs

By Jesse Valentine - September 02, 2026
Balkcom took $1,000 from Syngenta amid paraquat lawsuits

Balkcom took $1,000 from Syngenta amid paraquat lawsuits

By Jesse Valentine - September 02, 2026
New report: Trump’s food safety cuts are making people sick

New report: Trump’s food safety cuts are making people sick

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
NRSC ad falsely claims Turek wants to tax Social Security

NRSC ad falsely claims Turek wants to tax Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
These vulnerable Republicans have targeted Social Security

These vulnerable Republicans have targeted Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
Hinson backed tax credits that helped her husband’s company

Hinson backed tax credits that helped her husband’s company

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
The “Mike Spike”: Lawler under fire for rising costs

The “Mike Spike”: Lawler under fire for rising costs

By Jesse Valentine - August 31, 2026
Blanche, Hawley misrepresent key abortion case

Blanche, Hawley misrepresent key abortion case

By Jesse Valentine - August 28, 2026
Andy Biggs opposed online sex trafficking law

Andy Biggs opposed online sex trafficking law

By Jesse Valentine - August 27, 2026
Hinson missed multiple votes on Epstein investigation

Hinson missed multiple votes on Epstein investigation

By Jesse Valentine - August 27, 2026
John James has received millions from the DeVos family

John James has received millions from the DeVos family

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Fact check: GOP ad distorts claims about Troy Jackson’s son

Fact check: GOP ad distorts claims about Troy Jackson’s son

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Kiggans pushes false $21 million claim about Elaine Luria

Kiggans pushes false $21 million claim about Elaine Luria

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Paxton aide appears to back Social Security privatization

Paxton aide appears to back Social Security privatization

By Jesse Valentine - August 24, 2026
John Sununu put his sister on the campaign payroll

John Sununu put his sister on the campaign payroll

By Jesse Valentine - August 19, 2026
Honeycutt took $3,500 from ex-lawmaker convicted of bribery

Honeycutt took $3,500 from ex-lawmaker convicted of bribery

By Jesse Valentine - August 18, 2026
Whatley gave sex offender access to young people

Whatley gave sex offender access to young people

By Jesse Valentine - August 18, 2026
Nick Begich defended tariffs and outsourced jobs

Nick Begich defended tariffs and outsourced jobs

By Jesse Valentine - August 17, 2026
Mike Rogers took big donations from oil and gas

Mike Rogers took big donations from oil and gas

By Jesse Valentine - August 14, 2026
House Republicans embrace group that wants to privatize Social Security

House Republicans embrace group that wants to privatize Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Scott Timko’s business owes thousands in unpaid taxes

Scott Timko’s business owes thousands in unpaid taxes

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Ashley Hinson missed almost 200 votes in Congress

Ashley Hinson missed almost 200 votes in Congress

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Sununu backs privatizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Sununu backs privatizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

By Jesse Valentine - August 12, 2026
He took his wife to a Texas hospital for a miscarriage. She left in a body bag.

He took his wife to a Texas hospital for a miscarriage. She left in a body bag.

By Bonnie Fuller - August 12, 2026
GOP Senate candidates are threatening Medicare and Medicaid

GOP Senate candidates are threatening Medicare and Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - August 12, 2026
Chris Shea takes unpopular positions on Iran War, Medicaid

Chris Shea takes unpopular positions on Iran War, Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - August 11, 2026
Sununu profits as Americans pay more for gas, food and medicine

Sununu profits as Americans pay more for gas, food and medicine

By Jesse Valentine - August 10, 2026
John James voted to weaken Great Lakes protections

John James voted to weaken Great Lakes protections

By Jesse Valentine - August 06, 2026
Braun took drug industry money, opposed lower health care costs

Braun took drug industry money, opposed lower health care costs

By Jesse Valentine - August 04, 2026
Fact check: Ashley Hinson’s attack ad misrepresents Josh Turek

Fact check: Ashley Hinson’s attack ad misrepresents Josh Turek

By Jesse Valentine - August 04, 2026

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License .