search
Sections List
American Journal News

15 Republicans who refused to fill a SCOTUS seat in 2016 but want Trump to do it now

They did not think President Barack Obama should get to pick a Supreme Court justice in an election year.

By Josh Israel - September 21, 2020
Share
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX)

Republican senators who blocked confirmation hearings for Judge Merrick Garland, President Barack Obama’s pick to fill an empty Supreme Court seat four years ago, have already indicated they will push to confirm a Supreme Court nominee this year.

At least 15 Republicans who objected to confirming a Democratic president’s nominee in an election year are applying different standards to Donald Trump.

Less than 72 hours after Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death on Friday, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and more than 20 Senate Republicans are already pushing to rush through her replacement rather than waiting to see who wins the presidential election in November.

Most of those same Republicans backed McConnell’s refusal to even allow a confirmation hearing for Garland in 2016 — even though Justice Antonin Scalia died that February and it meant leaving the seat open for more than a year.

The flip-floppers include:

Lamar Alexander

“No one should be surprised that a Republican Senate majority would vote on a Republican President’s Supreme Court nomination, even during a presidential election year,” Alexander (TN) said Sunday in a statement. “The Constitution gives senators the power to do it. The voters who elected them expect it.”

John Barrasso

“The president is going to nominate and we’re going to vote this year,” Barrasso (WY) told NBC News on Sunday. “If we did something different now we would be breaking with the precedent that has long been established and if the president and the Senate are of the same party, you move along with confirmation.”

Roy Blunt

“Both the White House and the Senate have some obligation to do what they think in the majority in the Senate is the right thing to do,” Blunt (MO) told CBS News on Sunday, “and there is a Senate majority put there by voters for reasons like this.”

Tom Cotton

“The Senate will do its constitutional duty. We will process the president’s nomination for SCOTUS and conduct thorough and deliberate hearings,” Cotton (AR) tweeted on Sunday. “We will move forward without delay.”

Ted Cruz

“I believe that the president should next week nominate a successor to the court, and I think it is critical that the Senate takes up and confirms that successor before Election Day,” Cruz (TX) said Friday. “This nomination is why Donald Trump was elected. This confirmation is why the voters voted for a Republican majority in the Senate.”

Steve Daines

“We now face a clear choice. President Trump will nominate a well-qualified justice who will uphold our Constitution and protect our freedoms. The type of justice Montanans want on the Supreme Court,” Daines (MT) tweeted on Saturday. “I believe the Senate should move forward with confirming President Trump’s nominee.”

Lindsey Graham

Graham (SC) tweeted Saturday: “I will support President @realDonaldTrump in any effort to move forward regarding the recent vacancy created by the passing of Justice Ginsburg.”

Ron Johnson

“We had divided government (in 2016). That’s a valid argument when you have divided government, (to say) ‘Let’s let the American people decide.’ Right now, we don’t have divided government,” Johnson (WI) said in an interview with a local newspaper on Saturday. “That makes all the difference in the world.”

Mitch McConnell

“Americans reelected our majority in 2016 and expanded it in 2018 because we pledged to work with President Trump and support his agenda, particularly his outstanding appointments to the federal judiciary,” McConnell (KY) said in a statement on Friday. “President Trump’s nominee will receive a vote on the floor of the United States Senate.”

Jerry Moran

A spokesperson for Moran (KS) told a local paper Moran “agrees with Leader McConnell’s decision” to move forward with confirmation of a Trump nominee.

Rob Portman

“When the presidency and the Senate are controlled by the same party, the precedent is for the president’s nominees to get confirmed,” Portman (OH) said in a statement on Saturday. “I look forward to seeing who President Trump plans to nominate and thoroughly assessing his or her qualifications for this important role.”

Richard Shelby

“In the days ahead, I look forward to a solid conservative candidate being nominated and an expeditious confirmation process,” Shelby (AL) said in a statement on Saturday.

John Thune

“I believe Americans sent a Republican president and a Republican Senate to Washington to ensure we have an impartial judiciary that upholds the Constitution and the rule of law,” Thune (SD) said Friday. “We will fulfill our obligation to them. As Leader McConnell has said, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee will receive a vote on the floor of the U.S. Senate.”

Thom Tillis

Tillis (NC) said in a statement on Saturday: “Four years ago, a Supreme Court vacancy arose under divided government and a lame-duck president as Americans were choosing his successor. Today, however, President Trump is again facing voters at the ballot box and North Carolinians will ultimately render their judgment on his presidency and how he chooses to fill the vacancy.”

Roger Wicker

“President Trump and Senate Republicans promised to confirm well-qualified, conservative judges and justices to the federal courts,” Wicker (MS) said on Saturday in a statement. “We should continue to fulfill this promise and our constitutional duty for all vacancies as long as we are in office. I look forward to consideration of the President’s nominee by the full Senate.”

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
A Las Vegas woman’s abortion story—and why she’s voting yes on Question 6

A Las Vegas woman’s abortion story—and why she’s voting yes on Question 6

By Bonnie Fuller - September 04, 2026
Roger Marshall has an Epstein files problem

Roger Marshall has an Epstein files problem

By Jesse Valentine - September 04, 2026
Lahn’s running mate has deep ties to big ag

Lahn’s running mate has deep ties to big ag

By Jesse Valentine - September 03, 2026
Aaron Flint misleads voters about Montana’s congressional district

Aaron Flint misleads voters about Montana’s congressional district

By Jesse Valentine - September 03, 2026
Garrity helped lead super polluter that offshored jobs

Garrity helped lead super polluter that offshored jobs

By Jesse Valentine - September 02, 2026
Balkcom took $1,000 from Syngenta amid paraquat lawsuits

Balkcom took $1,000 from Syngenta amid paraquat lawsuits

By Jesse Valentine - September 02, 2026
New report: Trump’s food safety cuts are making people sick

New report: Trump’s food safety cuts are making people sick

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
NRSC ad falsely claims Turek wants to tax Social Security

NRSC ad falsely claims Turek wants to tax Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
These vulnerable Republicans have targeted Social Security

These vulnerable Republicans have targeted Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
Hinson backed tax credits that helped her husband’s company

Hinson backed tax credits that helped her husband’s company

By Jesse Valentine - September 01, 2026
The “Mike Spike”: Lawler under fire for rising costs

The “Mike Spike”: Lawler under fire for rising costs

By Jesse Valentine - August 31, 2026
Blanche, Hawley misrepresent key abortion case

Blanche, Hawley misrepresent key abortion case

By Jesse Valentine - August 28, 2026
Andy Biggs opposed online sex trafficking law

Andy Biggs opposed online sex trafficking law

By Jesse Valentine - August 27, 2026
Hinson missed multiple votes on Epstein investigation

Hinson missed multiple votes on Epstein investigation

By Jesse Valentine - August 27, 2026
John James has received millions from the DeVos family

John James has received millions from the DeVos family

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Fact check: GOP ad distorts claims about Troy Jackson’s son

Fact check: GOP ad distorts claims about Troy Jackson’s son

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Kiggans pushes false $21 million claim about Elaine Luria

Kiggans pushes false $21 million claim about Elaine Luria

By Jesse Valentine - August 25, 2026
Paxton aide appears to back Social Security privatization

Paxton aide appears to back Social Security privatization

By Jesse Valentine - August 24, 2026
John Sununu put his sister on the campaign payroll

John Sununu put his sister on the campaign payroll

By Jesse Valentine - August 19, 2026
Honeycutt took $3,500 from ex-lawmaker convicted of bribery

Honeycutt took $3,500 from ex-lawmaker convicted of bribery

By Jesse Valentine - August 18, 2026
Whatley gave sex offender access to young people

Whatley gave sex offender access to young people

By Jesse Valentine - August 18, 2026
Nick Begich defended tariffs and outsourced jobs

Nick Begich defended tariffs and outsourced jobs

By Jesse Valentine - August 17, 2026
Mike Rogers took big donations from oil and gas

Mike Rogers took big donations from oil and gas

By Jesse Valentine - August 14, 2026
House Republicans embrace group that wants to privatize Social Security

House Republicans embrace group that wants to privatize Social Security

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Scott Timko’s business owes thousands in unpaid taxes

Scott Timko’s business owes thousands in unpaid taxes

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Ashley Hinson missed almost 200 votes in Congress

Ashley Hinson missed almost 200 votes in Congress

By Jesse Valentine - August 13, 2026
Sununu backs privatizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

Sununu backs privatizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

By Jesse Valentine - August 12, 2026
He took his wife to a Texas hospital for a miscarriage. She left in a body bag.

He took his wife to a Texas hospital for a miscarriage. She left in a body bag.

By Bonnie Fuller - August 12, 2026
GOP Senate candidates are threatening Medicare and Medicaid

GOP Senate candidates are threatening Medicare and Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - August 12, 2026
Chris Shea takes unpopular positions on Iran War, Medicaid

Chris Shea takes unpopular positions on Iran War, Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - August 11, 2026
Sununu profits as Americans pay more for gas, food and medicine

Sununu profits as Americans pay more for gas, food and medicine

By Jesse Valentine - August 10, 2026
John James voted to weaken Great Lakes protections

John James voted to weaken Great Lakes protections

By Jesse Valentine - August 06, 2026
Braun took drug industry money, opposed lower health care costs

Braun took drug industry money, opposed lower health care costs

By Jesse Valentine - August 04, 2026
Fact check: Ashley Hinson’s attack ad misrepresents Josh Turek

Fact check: Ashley Hinson’s attack ad misrepresents Josh Turek

By Jesse Valentine - August 04, 2026
Ollivant campaign repeatedly shares incorrect district maps

Ollivant campaign repeatedly shares incorrect district maps

By Jesse Valentine - August 03, 2026
Mike Collins got rich on suspiciously timed crypto trades

Mike Collins got rich on suspiciously timed crypto trades

By Jesse Valentine - August 03, 2026
Jim Desmond campaigned with mayor who linked mask mandates to segregation

Jim Desmond campaigned with mayor who linked mask mandates to segregation

By Jesse Valentine - July 31, 2026
Claims Jon Husted protected sexual abusers date back more than 20 years

Claims Jon Husted protected sexual abusers date back more than 20 years

By Jesse Valentine - July 31, 2026
Tom Tiffany supported advancing extreme abortion ban in Congress

Tom Tiffany supported advancing extreme abortion ban in Congress

By Jesse Valentine - July 30, 2026
Finstad backed Trump tariffs as Minnesota farmers paid the price

Finstad backed Trump tariffs as Minnesota farmers paid the price

By Jesse Valentine - July 29, 2026
Ciscomani ad falsely claims Mendoza called parents “toxic”

Ciscomani ad falsely claims Mendoza called parents “toxic”

By Jesse Valentine - July 27, 2026
New Whatley ad distorts Cooper’s record on taxes

New Whatley ad distorts Cooper’s record on taxes

By Jesse Valentine - July 24, 2026

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License .