Democratic senator: GOP health care bill is "intellectual and moral garbage truck fire"
After making moves toward a bipartisan, publicly debated health care bill in the wake of their spectacular failure in July, Republicans unexpectedly started pushing to pass an even worse Obamacare repeal bill just before the deadline in two weeks, once again shutting out Democrats and only pretending to schedule a hearing. Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy […]
After making moves toward a bipartisan, publicly debated health care bill in the wake of their spectacular failure in July, Republicans unexpectedly started pushing to pass an even worse Obamacare repeal bill just before the deadline in two weeks, once again shutting out Democrats and only pretending to schedule a hearing.
Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut is having none of it.
In a furious thread on Twitter, Murphy proclaimed the new bill to be “an intellectual and moral garbage truck fire.”
THREAD: A short primer on all the ways the #GrahamCassidyBill is an intellectual and moral garbage truck fire. pic.twitter.com/X8IjLLay56
— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) September 18, 2017
The bill “eliminates protections for people who aren’t or have been sick,” Murphy explained.
“Lifetime caps, annual caps, charging older people more — the greatest hits of Trumpcare — all back again in Graham-Cassidy,” he added.
Murphy further attacked the bill for completely eliminating the Medicaid expansion and block-granting the program. “Millions will lose insurance, including loads of disabled and children. Many will die without care.”
The individual markets fare little better. “Premiums go up for everyone,” Murphy wrote. “20% in first year alone. Gets way worse after that if you are 50+ or making under 400% of poverty.”
One of Murphy’s biggest criticisms was the impact the bill would have on funding to the states:
6/ Even if states wanted to keep preexisting condition protections, they can't bc #GrahamCassidy gets rid of individual mandate.
— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) September 18, 2017
“Bottom line,” Murphy said, “Graham-Cassidy, written in secret, hurts millions, makes every problem in the health care system worse not better.”
Murphy wrapped up his criticism with a direct message to GOP senators who claimed to be concerned about protecting Medicaid funding, only to seriously consider voting for this bill, like West Virginia’s Shelley Moore Capito:
If you're a Republican who says you're concerned w potential Medicaid cuts & u vote for #GrahamCassidy, you've been lying. It GUTS Medicaid.
— Chris Murphy (@ChrisMurphyCT) September 18, 2017
Republicans have not changed their tune. They are back with a new plan that is even worse than what the American people resoundingly stood up and rejected — and they’re trying to get away with it because they think no one is paying attention. But Democratic senators like Murphy are paying attention, and they are fighting back to make sure this bill, like the others before it, fails.
Recommended
Miller-Meeks says costly insurance could lead to healthier lifestyles
The Republican congressperson said deductibles and copays require consumers to have “some skin in the game,” and that it may push them to exercise more or quit smoking.
By Jesse Valentine - February 18, 2026
Eliminating Obamacare tops Zach Nunn’s legislative wishlist
“I want the ACA gone,” Nunn said.
By Jesse Valentine - February 10, 2026
Husted took hundreds of thousands from insurers now raising Ohio rates
The increases come as many Ohioans are already struggling with health care costs.
By Jesse Valentine - February 04, 2026