search
Sections List
American Journal News

Town hall crowd boos GOP senator for brushing off woman with chronic illness

The Republican Party is still clinging to its secret health care repeal plan, despite the fact that the bill is massively unpopular. Millions of people would be harmed by the bill’s passage, and a new report shows that it would also lead to the loss of nearly one million jobs. But none of that has dissuaded […]

By Alison R. Parker - June 16, 2017
Share
Deb Fischer

The Republican Party is still clinging to its secret health care repeal plan, despite the fact that the bill is massively unpopular.

Millions of people would be harmed by the bill’s passage, and a new report shows that it would also lead to the loss of nearly one million jobs.

But none of that has dissuaded the GOP from trying to ram the bill through under cover of darkness.

Not even the pleas of their own frightened constituents are enough to change some Republican minds.

At a town hall meeting in Omaha, Nebraska, Sen. Deb Fischer was confronted by a number of angry and frustrated voters, who wanted explanations about the repeal plan and her support for it. Fischer had little of substance to offer in response.

One woman spoke bravely about her chronic autoimmune illness, for which her medications alone cost $75,000 a year. She explained that she was worried about the potential return of lifetime caps on coverage for medical care, which the Affordable Care Act barred.

And when she told Fischer, “I’m disappointed that you have not been more active on this,” the senator simply walked away, until the crowd shamed her into responding.

But her answer was not what they wanted to hear, and the chorus of boos made that clear.

WOMAN: My insurance has to pay for my $75,000 a year medication. So if you’re going to take those away, is there any way that you could then make drug costs less? Make — you know, what’s being proposed and what’s being [unintelligible] is not — it’s not good for anyone. And you know, I’d like to maintain my mobility, I’d like to not be on Social Security or Medicaid. I’d like to continue on the path that I’m on. But if my disease progresses and gets worse, you know, those are my options. I could commit a crime and go to prison and receive health care. I could potentially divorce my husband. [Fischer asks a question] Yes — I could divorce my husband and financially, you know, on paper, be poor.

So, you know, what’s going on, and what’s going on behind closed doors, is just absolutely disgusting. [applause] You know, it is 2017, and I’m really tired of having to fight for women’s health care. [applause][unintelligible] and only five Republican senators? I’m disappointed that you have not been more active on this. [applause]

[Fischer walks away]

CROWD: No response?

[Fischer walks back and asks a question of the woman off the microphone.]

FISCHER: I am supportive of the marketplace — [Boos and chants of “No!”] — and being able to have [unintelligible] where people can choose the benefits that they want. And I realize that there are many of you here today who are opposed to that.

At least Fischer accurately interpreted the sentiment of the audience. But it certainly doesn’t sound as though she took it, or the woman’s story, to heart.

This keeps happening: When they are not avoiding them altogether, Republicans are facing similar pleas for help and anger at their responses across the country.

Rep. Steve Knight of California was confronted by a woman who was afraid that her disabled son would lose his Medicaid coverage. Knight flatly lied to her, claiming that Medicaid “wouldn’t be changed” under the repeal plan.

In Idaho, Rep. Raúl Labrador was also challenged by a constituent over the Medicaid cuts, to which he shocking replied, “Nobody dies because they don’t have access to health care.”

In Kentucky, a man brought his medication and the pump he uses to deliver it right up to Rep. James Comer, telling him, “I want you to think about people like me” before voting to take away health care access.

Rep. Lee Zeldin of New York could barely be bothered to respond to a woman pleading with him on behalf of her heroin-addicted son.

And when South Carolina Rep. Joe Wilson tried to defend the repeal plan, he had his infamous “You lie!” moment thrown back in his face by the angry audience.

Indeed, as Virginia Rep. Dave Brat — a leader of the extremely conservative, all-male House Freedom Caucus — admitted recently, Republicans are “getting just annihilated” at town halls.

But if the GOP would like to change that reality, there is actually a very simple solution.

Don’t vote to take away people’s access to health care.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
I’m a Texan. But I don’t know if I can be a Texas OB-GYN

I’m a Texan. But I don’t know if I can be a Texas OB-GYN

By Bonnie Fuller - December 11, 2025
Lombardo blasted for backing DOGE over injured firefighters

Lombardo blasted for backing DOGE over injured firefighters

By Jesse Valentine - December 10, 2025
NEWSLETTER: corruption disguised as policy

NEWSLETTER: corruption disguised as policy

By Jesse Valentine - December 09, 2025
Trump calls affordability concerns a “hoax” despite dire economic data

Trump calls affordability concerns a “hoax” despite dire economic data

By Jesse Valentine - December 03, 2025
Van Epps touts endorsements from controversial, corrupt figures

Van Epps touts endorsements from controversial, corrupt figures

By Jesse Valentine - November 26, 2025
Mike Lawler’s ‘moderate’ brand collides with his far-right alliances

Mike Lawler’s ‘moderate’ brand collides with his far-right alliances

By Jesse Valentine - November 26, 2025
New report: Thanksgiving costs surge as Americans face higher grocery, travel expenses

New report: Thanksgiving costs surge as Americans face higher grocery, travel expenses

By Jesse Valentine - November 25, 2025
Collins failed to protect Mainers’ health care. She took a victory lap anyway.

Collins failed to protect Mainers’ health care. She took a victory lap anyway.

By Jesse Valentine - November 24, 2025
Whatley calls for replacing Obamacare with ‘market-driven solutions’

Whatley calls for replacing Obamacare with ‘market-driven solutions’

By Jesse Valentine - November 21, 2025
House GOP candidates stay silent on releasing Epstein files

House GOP candidates stay silent on releasing Epstein files

By Jesse Valentine - November 20, 2025
Veterans’ groups slam Trump’s march toward war with Venezuela

Veterans’ groups slam Trump’s march toward war with Venezuela

By Jesse Valentine - November 18, 2025
NEWSLETTER: Dick Cheney quietly exits the world he destroyed

NEWSLETTER: Dick Cheney quietly exits the world he destroyed

By Jesse Valentine - November 14, 2025
Is Karrin Robson trying to hide her anti-abortion record?

Is Karrin Robson trying to hide her anti-abortion record?

By Jesse Valentine - November 14, 2025
Wisconsin mom exposes painful reality of abortion laws after tragic pregnancy loss

Wisconsin mom exposes painful reality of abortion laws after tragic pregnancy loss

By Bonnie Fuller - November 13, 2025
Van Orden says Obamacare is a “failed program,” won’t commit to extending subsidies

Van Orden says Obamacare is a “failed program,” won’t commit to extending subsidies

By Jesse Valentine - November 12, 2025
GOP ‘Problem Solvers’ voted for deep Medicaid cuts they opposed

GOP ‘Problem Solvers’ voted for deep Medicaid cuts they opposed

By Jesse Valentine - November 12, 2025
Whatley campaign tied to company accused of preying on veterans

Whatley campaign tied to company accused of preying on veterans

By Jesse Valentine - November 06, 2025
‘Ticket to Ride’ and pickle sandwiches: The family life behind Abigail Spanberger’s campaign

‘Ticket to Ride’ and pickle sandwiches: The family life behind Abigail Spanberger’s campaign

By Bonnie Fuller - November 03, 2025
Republican John Reid says Confederate generals were “remarkable people”

Republican John Reid says Confederate generals were “remarkable people”

By Jesse Valentine - October 31, 2025
RFK Jr. is going to war against abortion pills

RFK Jr. is going to war against abortion pills

By Bonnie Fuller - October 31, 2025
Ciattarelli wants to end the immigration policy that made his family American

Ciattarelli wants to end the immigration policy that made his family American

By Jesse Valentine - October 31, 2025
Collins says she opposed GOP bill—then brags about writing it

Collins says she opposed GOP bill—then brags about writing it

By Jesse Valentine - October 28, 2025
Some of Jack Ciattarelli’s biggest donors have criminal records

Some of Jack Ciattarelli’s biggest donors have criminal records

By Jesse Valentine - October 27, 2025
GOP Rep. Mike Lawler raises money for radical anti-abortion group

GOP Rep. Mike Lawler raises money for radical anti-abortion group

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2025
Lavish White House spending persists as federal workers go unpaid

Lavish White House spending persists as federal workers go unpaid

By Jesse Valentine - October 22, 2025
Miyares’ record shows a long history of siding with landlords over renters

Miyares’ record shows a long history of siding with landlords over renters

By Jesse Valentine - October 16, 2025
Lombardo voted by mail. Now, he wants to restrict it.

Lombardo voted by mail. Now, he wants to restrict it.

By Jesse Valentine - October 15, 2025
Miller-Meeks digs in, says no to health care savings for Iowans

Miller-Meeks digs in, says no to health care savings for Iowans

By Jesse Valentine - October 14, 2025
Tom Barrett promoted GOP budget by passing off a political insider as a small business owner

Tom Barrett promoted GOP budget by passing off a political insider as a small business owner

By Jesse Valentine - October 10, 2025
Republican Rep. Rob Wittman under fire for fundraising during shutdown

Republican Rep. Rob Wittman under fire for fundraising during shutdown

By Jesse Valentine - October 08, 2025
Jason Miyares advanced an extreme anti-abortion agenda as Virginia attorney general

Jason Miyares advanced an extreme anti-abortion agenda as Virginia attorney general

By Jesse Valentine - October 07, 2025
NEWSLETTER: A new generation of Trump grifters

NEWSLETTER: A new generation of Trump grifters

By Jesse Valentine - October 06, 2025
Texas wanted to force her US Marine vet husband to watch their baby die—it would have been worse than war

Texas wanted to force her US Marine vet husband to watch their baby die—it would have been worse than war

By Bonnie Fuller - October 02, 2025
Tumblr linked to Republican John Reid engaged with Nazi porn accounts

Tumblr linked to Republican John Reid engaged with Nazi porn accounts

By Jesse Valentine - October 01, 2025
Spanberger speaks: How she’ll fight Medicaid cuts, create more affordable housing, and protect public schools

Spanberger speaks: How she’ll fight Medicaid cuts, create more affordable housing, and protect public schools

By Bonnie Fuller - September 25, 2025
Republican Josh Williams: I support tax breaks for the rich

Republican Josh Williams: I support tax breaks for the rich

By Jesse Valentine - September 25, 2025

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License .