search
Sections List
American Journal News

Despite promises, Facebook is still not removing antisemitic and Islamophobic hate speech

While 2021 has seen rises in antisemitic and anti-Muslim violence, Facebook has failed to enforce its hate speech policies.

By Josh Axelrod - August 04, 2021
Share
Mark Zuckerberg

Facebook failed to remove 90% of reported antisemitic content over a two-month period, according to a new study from the research and advocacy nonprofit organization Center for Countering Digital Hate, whose findings spotlight the extent of Facebook’s religious hate speech problem.

Throughout a six-week period in May and June 2021, researchers reported 714 blatantly antisemitic posts to Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, and TikTok to see how the platforms would respond. They found that the platforms removed fewer than one out of six reported posts, with Facebook ranking dead last in enforcement.

“As a result of their failure to enforce their own rules, social media platforms like Facebook have become safe places to spread racism and propaganda against Jews,” the center wrote in its study.

Between post views, followers of the posters’ accounts, and groups that shared the content, the reported antisemitic content could have been viewed by more than 7.3 million users.

Examples of content include a Facebook video, watched over 75,000 times, that blamed the 9/11 attacks on the Rothschild dynasty, a wealthy Jewish family whose power is often exaggerated by conspiracy theorists, as well as both public and private Facebook groups with tens of thousands of members making posts about how Jews control the U.S. government or are responsible for creating the coronavirus.

Facebook has long been criticized for insufficiently policing hate and misinformation on its platform, used by almost 3 billion monthly active users. Earlier this month, President Joe Biden lambasted the platform for allowing misinformation around vaccines and the coronavirus, accusing Facebook of “killing people.”

Stop Hate for Profit, a coalition that includes civil rights groups Color of Change and the NAACP, succeeded in mobilizing an advertising boycott over Facebook’s allowance of hate speech for all of July 2020. More than 1,000 companies halted ads on the platform, with some reducing their spending, some participated for just a month, and others boycotted for months after the initial campaign. While 98% of Facebook’s nearly $86 billion revenue comes from advertising, the boycott only exacted a minimal financial impact on the company, and its revenue actually rose during the boycott period.

The platform’s policies have evolved over time. In what Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg called “standing for free expression,” Facebook allowed content that distorted or denied the Holocaust until last October, when Zuckerberg reversed course.

And Facebook has pushed back on criticism, claiming to take a “zero tolerance approach” to hate speech. In an article titled “Facebook Does Not Benefit from Hate” posted in July 2020, Facebook official Nick Clegg wrote:

More than 100 billion messages are sent on our services every day. … In all of those billions of interactions a tiny fraction are hateful. When we find hateful posts on Facebook and Instagram, we take a zero tolerance approach and remove them.

 

[…]

 

Unfortunately, zero tolerance doesn’t mean zero incidences. With so much content posted every day, rooting out the hate is like looking for a needle in a haystack. We invest billions of dollars each year in people and technology to keep our platform safe. We have tripled — to more than 35,000 — the people working on safety and security. We’re a pioneer in artificial intelligence technology to remove hateful content at scale.

But critics have continued to charge Facebook with profiting from hate speech that circulates on its platform, arguing that its business model makes it less likely to take steps to remove content that keeps its users engaged with the site.

The Anti-Defamation League, a leading Jewish advocacy organization, has spent years exhorting Facebook to remove antisemitic content from its site. In June, the organization sent a letter to Facebook’s oversight board, an independent panel of about 20 former political leaders, activists, and journalists, taking it to task for a number of reported antisemitic posts the board permitted.

“Despite years of requests to address antisemitism, Facebook has failed to take sufficient action against posts, groups and users that promote antisemitism in clear contravention of the company’s community standards,” the letter says. “Facebook’s inaction has helped spread hatred of Jews and has contributed to historical high levels of antisemitism in America and antisemitism online and offline across the globe.”

Daniel Kelley, the associate director of the ADL’s Center for Technology and Society, said oftentimes the only way to get Facebook to take down antisemitic posts is through a public campaign, because the platform is more concerned with its public image than with a meaningful approach to tackling hate speech.

“Facebook has this content moderation-as-a-PR-concern mode of operating that’s deeply disingenuous,” Kelly told The American Independent Foundation.

Facebook declined to comment for this story.

A civil rights group filed suit in April against Facebook over enforcement of its stated policies on hateful content on its platform.

Muslim Advocates alleges that Facebook has deceived users time and time again by promising to remove hateful content while refusing to actually enforce its own policies.

The lawsuit cites a study from Elon University computer science professor Megan Squire, who conducted a social network analysis and found more than 1,800 anti-Muslim Facebook groups with over 700,000 members.

“The level of vitriol in anti-Muslim groups is just so high, it’s really just alarming,” Squire said in a phone call.

Advocates argue that Facebook’s refusal to remove groups and police hateful content has dangerous real-world implications. Reported incidences of antisemitic and Islamophobic violence continue to increase both domestically and worldwide.

“We don’t believe that this is healthy for our society — that you can so easily violate public community standards on a platform like Facebook by fomenting hate against others, organizing rallies with calls to arms against people in order to threaten and intimidate them with your weapons and violence,” Muslim Advocates staff attorney Sanaa Ansari told The American Independent Foundation. “And despite having these platform rules, this kind of organizing of threats and violent assault — that’s dangerous, prohibited action — is still taking place on the platform.” 

Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.


AJ News
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Read More
AJ News
Latest
How many will lose health insurance under the Republican bill? The CBO says 13.7 million.

How many will lose health insurance under the Republican bill? The CBO says 13.7 million.

By Jesse Valentine - May 23, 2025
Rep. Bresnahan sold shares in PA companies ahead of market drop

Rep. Bresnahan sold shares in PA companies ahead of market drop

By Jesse Valentine - May 21, 2025
Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

Senate Republicans confirm convicted felon as U.S. ambassador

By Jesse Valentine - May 20, 2025
Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

Texas women face prosecution for abortions if new bill becomes law

By Bonnie Fuller - May 16, 2025
It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

It’s not just Medicaid—House Republicans want to cut food stamps too

By Jesse Valentine - May 15, 2025
Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

Disability advocates arrested protesting GOP Medicaid cuts

By Jesse Valentine - May 14, 2025
Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

Republican Bill Huizenga cheers power plant funds he tried to block

By Jesse Valentine - May 12, 2025
Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

Jack Ciattarelli called harmful tariffs a “grand experiment”

By Jesse Valentine - May 09, 2025
Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

Paul LePage, a Medicaid critic, launches congressional bid in Maine

By Jesse Valentine - May 06, 2025
Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

Earle-Sears ignored trans issues in office—now she uses them as a wedge

By Jesse Valentine - May 05, 2025
Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

Trump effectively shuts down campaign finance watchdog

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

Ciattarelli wants a DOGE-style commission to crack down on New Jersey Medicaid recipients

By Jesse Valentine - April 30, 2025
House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

House Republicans roll out new plan to decimate Medicaid

By Jesse Valentine - April 24, 2025
Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

Trump White House plans to garnish wages of student loan borrowers

By Jesse Valentine - April 22, 2025
Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

Megadonor embroiled in ethics scandal gave thousands to Winsome Earle-Sears

By Jesse Valentine - April 21, 2025
“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

“I Was Terrified To Get Pregnant Again After Having to Flee Tennessee for a Life-Saving Abortion”

By Bonnie Fuller - April 21, 2025
Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

Goldman Sachs: Trump’s tariffs will lead to job losses

By Jesse Valentine - April 17, 2025
Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

Democrats take stand for wrongly deported Maryland man

By Jesse Valentine - April 16, 2025
North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

North Carolina law would make it illegal for Democratic AG to sue Trump

By Jesse Valentine - April 11, 2025
Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

Older Americans suffer under Republican slash and burn policies

By Jesse Valentine - April 09, 2025
Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

Scott Brown got Trump’s tariff plans for New Zealand very wrong

By Jesse Valentine - April 08, 2025
Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

Trump admin canceled Social Security contracts to punish Maine governor

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

Senate Republicans vote to eliminate cap on overdraft fees

By Jesse Valentine - April 03, 2025
Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

Forced to carry a dying baby, this Texas mother of four says she didn’t think it could happen to her

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025
Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

Despite pleas from women and doctors, Texas may implement even more abortion restrictions

By Bonnie Fuller - March 28, 2025